What is the future of our natural landscapes?
What is the future of our references,
of our identity?
What is the future of our memories?
Fire is a sharp weapon.
Visitor’s Guide
The black of night filled the infinite space of the lagoon and the dense tropical forest that surrounded it. Actually, it was an almost pitch-black, as the starry sky was duplicated onto the dark water mirror of New Lagoon, mixing the brightness of the stars above with that of the scales of the fish below. The silence was also an almost silence, since it shared its space with the sound of animals that slept and those that did not. The humic smell and white mist evaporated from the water and expanded into the almost pitch-black. Along with the night, the boat flowed into the smell and mist. We stopped there on the water waiting for the transcendental moment that was about to happen. We stayed there, still, breathing in communion with those who slept and those who didn't. At a certain moment, we saw the silhouette of a mountain take form in the infinity. And then another. And the alchemy of the sun transmuted the almost pitch black into blue and then into red. The mist absorbed the celestial blush for itself and spread it throughout New Lagoon. The evaporating water and its floating lilies found themselves turned to a mysterious, ethereal crimson. All of this happened in a tiny fraction of time and in near silence. There was no applause. As the boat returned to the base, we, who had just witnessed the sublime, thought to ourselves:
– “This spectacle happens every day at dawn at the New Lagoon.”
– “And hardly anyone sees it…”
When the field work was finished and the rolls of film had been developed, I would move onto the next step, which was to burn the films – the films that I myself had photographed. Despite having already planned this step well (which included experimenting with fire in different ways on test films and visually mapping the specific burning process that I would perform on each of the frames), I kept putting off the actual moment of burning, like someone who postpones a crime that she will commit. I was trying to postpone the pain. The pain of aggression, the pain of irreversibility. The pain of the impossibility of revisiting that landscape in that unique vision of its existence. The pain of violating such places of beauty and teachings. The pain of destroying something that is so cared for by the analogue photographer: the original. After the burning, there would remain something mutilated and in a way that I still couldn't even know, since fire is a powerful weapon, a weapon that one can't completely control. Furthermore, all the effort to find and get to that exact spot, obtain the desired light and the proper camera position, would be consumed by the crackling of the flame once in contact with the photographic chemical and celluloid. And so I kept putting off the act, day after day. Would I be criticized for burning original pieces? I remembered the fire at the National Film Archive and at the National Museum, the Pantanal region, the Brazilian savanna and the Amazon fires, the villages burnt during the countless wars of our history, the books burned by the Nazi regime, I remembered all these acts that, having taken place in the past and myself living in the present, had denied me the possibility of understanding valuable things that are part of my own history. I remembered that this work of mine proposed to emulate these violent acts, using the same element to this end, and thus symbolically remembering them, since violations that are not remembered by society tend not to be fought and, consequently, to be repeated in the future. In the end, the crime I proposed for me to commit took place: holding my breath I lit the match and brought the photogram closer to the flame. The landscape burned and deformed. I remembered all those fires. Once again, I was outraged. I felt the pain.
On August 27, in 2019, I read on BBC News Brazil: [quote] “August 10th can be classified as a key moment in recent Amazon history. It is now known as the 'Day of Fire', when rural producers in the northern region of Brazil are said to have started an organised movement to set fire to areas of the largest tropical forest in the world. This suspicion is being investigated by the Federal Police and the Federal Prosecutors’ Office. This Monday, the General Attorney of the Republic said there were indications of an 'orchestrated action' to set fire to several forest areas. […] The first news about this was published on August 5 by the Folha do Progresso newspaper, in the city of Novo Progresso, state of Pará. The article reported a conversation with a leading producer of the town who promised to promote forest fires on the 10th. The text read, '(The Producers) want the 10th of August to get the attention of the authorities. (...) The development of local production is taking place without government support. We need to show the president that we want to work, and the only way is by taking the forest down. To shape and clear our pastures we need fire'. Satellite data collected by the Brazilian National Institute for Space Research and compiled by the Pará State Secretariat for the Environment show that, as of August 10th, there was a significant increase of fires in forest areas. This increase occurred mainly in forest reserves in the municipalities of Novo Progresso, Altamira and São Félix do Xingu. On the 10th, Novo Progresso presented 124 active fire records, a 300% increase from the previous day. Altamira recorded 154 fires between the 6th and 8th of August. In the next three days, from August 9 to 11, 431 fires were detected in the city, a 179% increase in three days. São Félix do Xingu presented a more significant increase: between the 6th and 8th of August, the municipality registered 67 outbreaks. In the next three days, 288 were observed, a 329% increase in three days.” [end quote]
A few days after the “Day of Fire”, the black smoke arrived in São Paulo, over 1200 miles away from where the fire had taken place, and day became night in the largest city of the Americas.
During the burning of the photographic film I noticed that my fingerprint remained on the molten emulsion, merging the identity of the perpetrator with it. That reminded me of Nina Berman during a deep conversation the two of us had last year about visual narratives that chronicle themes of violence, injustice and violations of Human and Nature Rights. She said: "one must show the perpetrator and not only their victims."
In 2020, the Pantanal, one of the planet's megadiversity regions and the world's largest floodplain, experienced an unprecedented fire season, where a third of its area was turned into ash and at least 17 million animals burned to death. In a geographical and temporal dimension, it was as if more than half of Switzerland had been burnt in just nine months. That year, more than 90% of fires were started by human action and the extremely dry air, strong wind, logistical difficulties, negligence and the consequent lack of equipment, water and personnel created hell, where a few firefighters, veterinarians and biologists made superhuman efforts and countless animals found themselves trapped, many succumbing to the flames. What happened in the Pantanal in those months was worthy of an apocalyptic chronicle: the flames jumped from one place to another, seeming to come out of nowhere, as the peat in the soil allowed much of the fire to go underground. Consequently, that fire was invisible to the eyes but felt on every paw and foot fleeing from the large flames that spread in an unpredictable direction. Animals and rescue teams were witnesses to, and victims of, an ecocide. In the photographs and videos produced on site, the fire line and smoke were so extensive that it seemed impossible to extinguish them; animals were dying or were reached too late, already charred. Those were difficult images to look at without being terrified. Despite the horror that was reported daily in all national and international media and the analyses that pointed out the causes, and their prevention, the scenario in the Pantanal region managed to repeat itself in an even more cruel fashion in the following year of 2021.
Through my research I found an article published on the 4th of September, 2020 on Mato Grosso Government's website: [quote] "Expert reports by the Integrated Multi-agency Center for Operational Coordination indicate that fires recorded in the Pantanal region of the State of Mato Grosso were caused by human action. The reports were forwarded to the Environment Police Department so that an investigation can be opened, and the offenders held accountable. […] At the Sesc Pantanal Private Natural Heritage Reserve, in the Barão de Melgaço region, the cause of the fire was given as the intentional burning of deforested vegetation to create a cattle pasture area on a local farm, which encroached on the nature reserve. Using aircraft from the Brazilian Air Force the team scanned the area and found the use of wood, fence posts, wires and ropes. Nearby, the team also found diesel fuel canisters that appeared to have been used to ignite piles of overturned plant material. […]” [end quote]
“It was a Sunday. The 2nd of September, 2018. From between 7:30 pm and into the early hours of Monday, the 3rd, Brazil watched a part of its own history become lost to fire. Most of the 20 million items that the National Museum housed were completely destroyed. Amongst them, the oldest human fossil found in the country, Luzia, as well as the Egyptian collection acquired by Dom Pedro I, the collection of Greco-Roman art, artifacts of Empress Teresa Cristina and palaeontology collections that included the fossil of a dinosaur from the state of Minas Gerais. […] Researchers, historians, and Museum employees raced to the site to help contain the flames. […] When the fire was eventually put out, around 3 am of Monday morning, the museum staff mourned the destruction of 90% of the collection.”
The Correio Brasiliense newspaper, September 2, 2021. Title of the article: “Fire at the National Museum, in Rio de Janeiro, turns three years old: remember”
It was a Sunday. I casually passed through the living room of my house, where the nightly news was being watched, when I was suddenly taken aback by the image of high flames seen from a helicopter and the journalist saying “the fire at the National Museum”. Astonished, I stopped and watched ('was this really happening?!'). I had visited the museum at the end of the year, and I could remember my fascination with the collection and how it had been exquisitely exhibited to allow us to know our history: as a planet, as a species, as a civilization, as a being. The roar of flames merged with the ominous hum of the helicopters announced the destruction of our biological, social and cultural heritage that was taking place overnight. On TV, the images of overwhelming flames that broke out through the windows and ceiling of each room of the mansion were broadcast live. In my mind's eye, I saw Luzia, the giant sloth, the tyrannosaurus: everything on fire, until it was reduced to a fine powder that would then be annihilated once and for all by the wind. When the fire was eventually put out, around 3 am of Monday morning, my memories became silenced.
“A fire broke out in a shed at the Brazil’s National Film Archive in São Paulo. […] One million documents from Embrafilme, the now defunct National Film Company, including screenplays, paper archives, original film prints and old equipment, were kept in this building. Some were over 100 years old and were destined for a Museum about the history of the Brazilian film industry. […] Earlier this year in April, National Film Archive's workers had warned of the institution’s state of abandonment and demanded clarification from the National Film Institute regarding the emergency plan announced by Secretary of Culture Mário Frias in December 2020. Carlos Magalhães a former director of the National Film Archive, immediately visited the site of the fire and stated 'Such is the state of the memory of Brazil's Film Industry. Devastation. Total devastation. Heart-wrenching...’[…]”
Evening News, Rede Globo channel, July 29, 2021. Title of the article: “Fire hits one of the National Film Archive's sheds in São Paulo”
“The indigenous Guarani Kaiowá people's prayer house was criminally burnt down this Saturday, October 2, in the community of Tekoha Guapo'y, located in the municipality of Amambai, in the state of Mato Grosso do Sul. Elizeu Guarani, the executive coordinator of the Brazilian Indigenous People's Council and of the General Assembly of the Kaiowá and Guarani people, declares: ‘We are sad because it is our sacred temple. With much sacrifice we built it and now in the blink of an eye it has been burnt down.”
Brazilian Indigenous People's Council, October 3, 2021, on a social network.
“People, listen, I am back here to ask for help. Outlaws are wreaking havoc in the Municipality of Anapu [state of Pará], as are the operations of the powerful land grabbers of the Amazon. The community of sector 96 is exposed, as well as the other peasant farmer settlements. Despite the court order, the police are not protecting the community of sector 96, where last week two families were taken hostage and two houses were burned down. There are 25 children there, and they are terrified. One of these children, when she saw her father leaving their home this morning, said: 'Dad, don't go, because they will burn down our house!’. […]”
Eliane Brum, May 17, 2022, on a social network.
Focusing on fires that are taking place within the Brazilian territory, the majority of them criminal, OPEN FIRE embodies the violence of recent acts against natural and cultural heritage and exposes the damage they have caused, in a multi-voice narrative.
The work is founded on the intertwined relationship that photography holds with its subject and its use as a safeguard for our collective memory. The work develops as follows: first, the author takes medium-format analogue photographs of sites of high relevance for conservation in Brazil. After being processed, the photographic film is systematically burnt by the artist – reproducing the aggression that has been openly inflicted upon the actual landscapes onto their photographic representations. After burning them, the resulting three-dimensional pieces are digitized, edited, and then juxtaposed with the author's thoughts and everyday experiences that relate to this issue, highlighting the context to which those images belong. As such, this online exhibition aims to serve as an invitation to debate pressing socioenvironmental, historical and political issues.
Open Fire is the result of my reflections as visual artist, researcher, and citizen in the face of the current situation of violent and rapid loss of our natural and cultural heritage as a consequence of fires.
Over the last few years, we have lived moments of anguish and indignation as witnesses of flames that mercilessly devour Brazil, consuming landscapes, lives, and our very identity. The visuals and data published – which reveal the severity of the devastation – are so alarming that they have caused a state of collective shock. After all, what does remain after fire violates the earth and life on it? What is left for the future, to be seen, recognized, remembered? This fire makes me reflect on the vulnerability and fragility of things – things that are part of our history and our identity (as individuals, as communities, as a society) – and the importance of safeguarding them.
I undertake OPEN FIRE underpinned by the intertwined relationship that photography holds with its subject and its use as a safeguard for our collective memory. My methodology consists of taking photographs of natural landscapes using a medium-format analogue camera. The chosen landscapes are located in sites defined as of outstanding relevance for biodiversity conservation in Brazil. After processing the photographic film, which refers to the natural landscapes I have photographed, I deliberately burn it, emulating the violent, destructive acts that have taken place in various places around the world throughout History, when the same fire-element swept away natural and cultural environments. At the next stage, the three-dimensional pieces that result from these burnings are digitized, edited, and juxtaposed with the insights and everyday experiences I have concerning this subject. This interweaving of visual and textual material creates a multi-voice narrative which contextualises the work and echoes the dimension of the issue.
Despite having photographs of natural sites at its core, this work is not limited to drawing attention to the destruction of natural heritage alone, but also explores the annihilation of another Brazilian landscape by means of fire: our cultural heritage (take as an example the fires at the National Museum, the Portuguese Language Museum and the Brazilian National Film Archive).
As such, OPEN FIRE aims to encourage debate around an issue that is environmental, social, historical and political: an issue that urges to be discussed in a framework in which society would play the role of protagonist and not of spectator and accomplice.
This work also aims to contribute to research in art practice, notably in the fields of experimentation and expanded photography. The interaction with the audience in this online environment seeks to motivate critical thinking, contribute to knowledge and expand the access to the arts.
Disclaimer: In the subjective audio descriptions some names have been omitted to avoid exposing individuals and also to facilitate the flow of narration.
THIS WORK HAS BEEN AWARDED THE FUNARTE MARC FERREZ PHOTOGRAPHY PRIZE
AND WAS ALSO SUPPORTED BY THE ARTMOSPHERE FINE ART.
To the staff of the Serra do Cipó National Park, Rio Doce State Park, Sumidouro State Park, and Serra do Rola-Moça State Park, with special regards to Edward Elias Júnior, Vinícius Moreira, Bárbara Evellyn Vitor Calazans, Jailma Soares, Claudia Silene Nunes Pinto, Sebastião Leandro Pinto, Marlon Araújo de Souza, Romário Aparecido da Silva, Renato Lima Magalhães, Marcos Lima Francisco, Gabriel Coura Assis, Cintia Avelar Palhares, Rodrigo Teribele, Érika Aparecida de Oliveira, Elaine Pereira de Souza, José Geraldo Pereira Nogueira, Jair de Miranda Pinto, Evandro Pereira Nogueira; to fieldwork assistants Gabriela Souza, Daniel Guedes, and Cyro Almeida; to Paulo Baptista, for welcoming this work when it was still in its outset; to Flávia Peluzzo, for our exchanges in the challenge that was the editing of the resulting pieces; to Rodrigo Zeferino, for the dialogues regarding the field work at the Rio Doce State Park; to Cyro Almeida, for his collaboration at different moments of this project and for kindly allowing his analogue cameras to be with me in all these landscapes; to Julio Molina, for his great partnership and affection in this and other twists and turns of life; to Alessandra Rosso and Luis Rodrigo Cerqueira, for the good vibes, before, during and after the editing; to PrevFogo, firefighters, rescue teams and volunteers, for their efforts, dedication and commitment to life.
Work title: Open Fire
Author: Marilene Ribeiro
Photography and interventions: Marilene Ribeiro
Texts: Marilene Ribeiro + various sources
Reviews by: Sue Branford, Marcela Bonfim, and Marcelo Salazar
Fieldwork assistants: Gabriela Souza, Daniel Guedes, and Cyro Almeida
Photographic film processing: Pedro Cine Foto and Super Camera
Digital scanning: Artmosphere Fine Art
English translation: Rachel Ann Hauser Davis
Narration: Cristiane Kopp and Marilene Ribeiro
Graphic design: Luciana DElboux
Web design: Christiano Amaral
Sponsored by: Funarte
Get to know about the author
References
"This is an extremely powerful and innovative exhibition. Marilene has deliberately used fire as a weapon to deface her photos of extremely beautiful natural phenomena, like the first moments of dawn over a lagoon, with all the unexpected, subtle colours that pierce the near-pitch black of the night. The defaced photos are weird, unsettling yet strangely beguiling. For those who have seen wildfires in the Amazon, ignited by rapacious land thieves, the similarities are uncanny. Both show, on the one hand, the fearful destructiveness of fire, above all when it is out of control, and on the other hand its bewitching beauty. It brings to mind the Yanomami myth of the creation of fire: Sanema-Yanomami Indians tricked Iwá, the caiman who owned fire by hiding it in his mouth; they told him such a ridiculous joke that he couldn't help roaring with laughter and unwittingly opened his mouth, allowing a Yanomami to steal the fire. But the fire proved hard to control -- the caiman's wife tried to put it out by peeing on it, but failed. Fire took refuge in the in the heart of the sacred tree, Pulo. After that, the Yanomami could only have access to fire by approaching the Pulo tree with all the respect due to a sacred object.
This exhibition subtly highlights the danger of using fire indiscriminately, without the care shown by the Yanomami. The very title, Open Fire, is a reference to the onslaught of land thieves and cattle rearers on Brazil's forests. They don't use fire with caution, as a means of domesticating plants and harmoniously combining the need of forest dwellers for small patches of cleared forest with the respect for the forest they need for their survival. Instead, they use it as a weapon of destruction, allowing it to escalate out of control, causing huge damage to natural systems, local inhabitants and eventually to the arsonists themselves. In this way, the exhibition is a reflection on the global process of the violent, greedy occupation of the natural world by outsiders, anxious only to make money, without taking into account the destruction they do, It is this which is making the planet uninhabitable."
(Sue Branford – journalist, Mongabay, Latin America Bureau, and former BBC editor)
"Between lit and unlit worlds, times and spaces coexist, and, in that cosmos we attempt to absorb the sensitive field of photography in a more conscious fashion. On this path, possibilities are also opened up to us from the burning of an ‘Open Fire’, which also feeds landscapes where apparently only destruction can be seen. A burning which holds a close relationship with the infinite state of the compositions, also aware that de-composing turns to be the very nature of our journeys, as it has been for the photographic film, which, in its turn, reveals the path of air, combustion and decomposition of time. Therefore, perceiving these phenomena becomes an experience of living them from their very core. Experience that can lead us to other destinations, such as those of the politics, ecology, identity, and the humanities. And those are layers which Marilene Ribeiro offers to us in this visual feast of meaning and connexions, as she feeds herself on very Nature as well as on its resonances on issues which are already changing the world. Noteworthy, OPEN FIRE exposes these matters in a time-space that is already future."
(Marcela Bonfim – photographer, visual thinker)
* References for the subjective audio descriptions:
The audio descriptions of this exhibition follow the guidelines of the Brazilian Technologic Centre of Accessibility and the Dorina Nowill Foundation for Blind People.